Released Opinions
August 20, 2021

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Civil Causes Decided

 

Case Number

Style

Disposition

Judges

 

 

 

 

 

 

05-19-00274-CV

Steward Health Care System LLC and Southwest General Hospital, LP v. Frank Saidara-- Appeal from 193rd Judicial District Court of Dallas County

Affirmed

Chief Justice Burns
Justice Myers
Justice Schenck
Justice Molberg
Justice Osborne
Justice Partida-Kipness
Justice Pedersen
Justice Reichek
Justice Nowell
Justice Carlyle
Justice Goldstein
Justice Smith
Justice Garcia

 

Opinion Issued En Banc Justice  Myers  PDF

Dissenting Opinion Justice  Carlyle  PDF

Concurring Opinion Chief Justice  Burns  PDF

Concurring Opinion Justice  Schenck  PDF Corrected

Concurring and Dissenting Opinion Justice  Osborne  PDF

 

 

05-19-01445-CV

Montgomery J. Bennett and Evan (Van) Lane Shaw v. Matthew Zucker-- Appeal from 330th Judicial District Court of Dallas County

Affirmed

Justice Osborne
Justice Pedersen
Justice Nowell

 

Memorandum Opinion Justice  Osborne  PDF

 

 

05-20-00050-CV

Winstead PC v. Dewey M. Moore, Jr.-- Appeal from 44th Judicial District Court of Dallas County

Affirmed in Part and Reversed and Remanded in Part

Justice Schenck
Justice Smith
Justice Garcia

 

Opinion Issued Justice  Garcia  PDF

Dissenting Opinion Justice  Schenck  PDF

 

 

05-20-00050-CV

Winstead PC v. Dewey M. Moore, Jr.-- Appeal from 44th Judicial District Court of Dallas County

Otherwise Disposed

Justice Molberg

 

Dissenting Opinion From Denial of En Banc Consideration Justice  Molberg  PDF

 

 

05-20-00050-CV

Winstead PC v. Dewey M. Moore, Jr.-- Appeal from 44th Judicial District Court of Dallas County

Otherwise Disposed

Justice Schenck

 

Concurring Opinion to Denial of En Banc Consideration Justice  Schenck  PDF

 

 

05-20-00488-CV

Montgomery J. Bennett v. Matthew Zucker-- Appeal from 330th Judicial District Court of Dallas County

Affirmed

Justice Osborne
Justice Pedersen
Justice Nowell

 

Memorandum Opinion Justice  Nowell  PDF

 

 

05-21-00449-CV

LeForce Entertainment, LLC v. Adam Morgan-- Appeal from 68th Judicial District Court of Dallas County

Dismissed

Chief Justice Burns
Justice Molberg
Justice Smith

 

Memorandum Opinion Chief Justice  Burns  PDF

 

 

05-21-00477-CV

Customer Service Quality Transportation, Inc. v. Keelen Jackson-- Appeal from 193rd Judicial District Court of Dallas County

Dismissed

Justice Schenck
Justice Reichek
Justice Carlyle

 

Memorandum Opinion Justice  Reichek  PDF

 

 

 

 

Criminal Causes Decided

 

Case Number

Style

Disposition

Judges

 

 

 

 

 

 

05-20-00197-CR

Tyran Darnell Shumate v. The State of Texas-- Appeal from 204th Judicial District Court of Dallas County

Reversed and Remanded

Justice Schenck
Justice Osborne
Justice Partida-Kipness

 

Memorandum Opinion Justice  Osborne  PDF